Argentinas alejandro agresti is to bring the life story of pope francis to the big screen, reports variety. Pope joan by donna woolfolk cross book club discussion. I found the film version of the pope joan story compelling viewing because it conveyed the force and importance of joan s spiritual calling yet portrayed her as an breathing human being this may be somewhat ironic since it is possible she is only a legend. Though most scholars believe the tale to be mere myth, the concept has yielded several stories that have explored the more romantic elements of its circumstances. After finishing donna cross novelization of joan s life, one may want her to be a real person, only because it is so gratifying to read about those rare heroes whose strength of vision enables them to ignore the almost overpowering messages of their own historical periods. Pope joan soundtrack 1972 movie soundtracks for sale. Why was one joan expunged from history books and the other made a saint. Pope joan, legendary female pontiff who supposedly reigned, under the title of john viii, for slightly more than 25 months, from 855 to 858, between the pontificates of st. The story of the female pontiff was previously examined in the littleknown 1972 film pope joan, featuring ingmar bergman muse liv ullmann. After a muted critical response, the film was severely reedited.
Supposedly, pope joan succeeded pope leo iv, a very saintly man credited with. Pope joan biography birthday, trivia german mythical. Pope joan 1972 michael anderson, liv ullmann, jeremy. The film has a truly glittering cast with liv ullman in the title role, costarring with trevor howard.
The story, popularized by 12th and th century chroniclers especially a dominican friar named martin of troppau. Pope joan is in completed starring john goodman, johanna wokalek, david wenham. Movies like pope joan 1972 if you like pope joan you are looking for atmospheric, serious and captivating movies about with pope, clergy, religions or cults, gender bending, ambition, legends and myths and society themes of drama and history genre shot in uk. Everything you need to know about pope joan movie completed. The clandestine affair from which pope joan s child was conceived is a sordid, grotty scene, totally lacking any passion.
Pope joan 1972 cast and crew a midwestern evangelist liv ullmann thinks she is a reincarnated ninthcentury pope and explains why to a psychiatrist keir dullea. Anderson, categoryclassicfilms, categoryuk, film movie classic, pope joan. Her visit becomes an absurd, decadent, oversexed version of alice in wonderland, with marcello mastroianni as the maddest of mad hatters and roman polanski a kinky march hare. Digitally remastered edition of the soundtrack to the 1972 film composed by the late maurice jarre. Supposedly, pope joan succeeded pope leo iv, a very saintly man credited with several miracles, who died on july 17, 855. I bought on the cheap and read the lawrence durrell translation of pope joan from the greek of emmanuel royidis some years ago and was surprised when i found i thoroughly enjoyed it. The story was widely believed for centuries, but most modern scholars regard it as fictional. Marcel barsotti there has long been speculation about the stories of a female pope in the middle ages, and catholics have been historically divided on whether this legend is fact or myth. Apr 16, 2015 such a dedicated, knowledgable and respected monk would have proven an ideal candidate to become pope. Here is a woman who hears gods voice and the voice of carnal longing.
Pope joan quotes showing 125 of 25 as for will, woman should be considered superior to man for eve ate of the apple for love of knowledge and learning, but adam ate of it merely because she asked him. Female travelled to europe, disguised as a monk shows great learning and piety elected pope in around 855 under the name john viii in 857 when, in procession on the way to st. Pope joan is a card game of the stops type, named after a legendary female pope of the 9th century. Because this film was such a disaster, i do not see any film maker daring to touch this subject again. Pope joan is a 1972 american mediaeval costume drama film based on the story of pope joan. The story of her papal rise and fall when she gave birth in public on a street in rome has plagued the. First, pope joan is not listed in the liber pontificalis the official documented listing of the popes which has chronological veracity. Pope joan 1972 michael anderson, herbert wise synopsis. Pope joan is a lush period piece, but first and foremost an exceptional bildungsroman. A 9th century woman of english extraction born in the german city of ingelheim disguises herself as. Even though modern consensus generally disputes pope joan as. This film when shown in america was called the devils imposture.
Pope joan, which depicts a female pontiff rumoured to have existed in. Filmed in 1972 as pope joan, the tale centred around a 20th century woman who believes she is the reincarnation of the legendary 9th century female pope. Based on the medieval legend of pope joan, who was made pope for a brief period around 855 a. Though most scholars believe the tale to be mere myth, the concept has yielded several stories that have explored the more. In the 9th century, pope joan wore the holy robes for more than two years before her deception was dramatically revealed. If you like pope joan you are looking for atmospheric, serious and captivating movies about with pope, clergy, religions or cults, gender bending, ambition, legends and myths and society themes of drama and history genre shot in uk. These were all removed to create a more linear story and the film was then released as the devils imposter. Pope joan introduction since 1970 the british public has been treated to several books, a radio drama and a london stage play, asserting that at one time a woman reigned as pope. A 9th century woman of english extraction born in the german city of mainz disguises herself as a man and rises through the vatican ranks. Cadavre exquis exquisite corpse with yves tanguy, joan miro, max morise, and.
That said, i found pope joan to be a wellwritten, thought provoking, and fully engaging novel. Drama historisch film geregisseerd door michael anderson. As for will, woman should be considered superior to man for eve ate of the apple for love of knowledge and learning, but adam ate of it merely because she asked him. A nonfiction film, usually lasting no more than one to two minutes, showing. The version of the film released in 1972 differed significantly from the version that had originally been filmed. A 9th century woman of english extraction born in the german city of ingelheim disguises herself as a man and rises through the vatican ranks. The film was edited with flashbacks and flashforwards. This movie is based on the medieval legend of pope joan, who was made pope for a brief period around 855 a.
The story of her papal rise and fall when she gave birth in public on a street in rome has plagued the catholic church and confounded researchers for centuries. A young american woman sydne rome traveling through italy finds herself in a strange mediterranean villa where nothing seems right. Its definitely your brain dealing with the lack of feel good juice. A popular british stageplay called top girls has pope joan. It has subsequently been proved that a gap of only a few weeks fell between. A full length film in 1972, entitled pope joan, also presented her as its central character. I swear it a presentday female evangelist strongly feels that she resembles the legendary pope joan and goes to see her psychiatrist in hopes of discovering that shes pope joan incarnate. Female pope film sparks vatican row film the guardian. Some chronicles reckon that pope joan wasnt promptly executed for heresy, but imprisoned for a number of years and forced to undergo penance for what she was said to have done. I found the film version of the pope joan story compelling viewing because it conveyed the force and importance of joans spiritual calling yet portrayed her as an breathing human being this may be somewhat ironic since it is possible she is only a legend. At least thats what legend and hundreds of medieval records claim. Directed by sonke wortmann, it stars johanna wokalek as joan, david wenham as gerold, her lover, and john goodman as pope sergius ii. The fable about a female pope, who afterwards bore the name of johanna joan, is first noticed in the middle of the thirteenth century.
An extensive authors note at the end contributes to this by asserting that the legend of pope joan was widely accepted as true until the midseventeenth century when the vatican expunged any reference joan in the papal records. The main proofs against the pope joan fable are as follows. This is an earlier version of the world of the popular greek film politiki kouzinaa. After finishing donna cross novelization of joans life, one may want her to be a real person, only because it is so gratifying to read about those rare heroes whose strength of vision enables them to ignore the almost overpowering messages of their own historical periods. Derived from the greek words bios life and morphe form, a term referring to. What similarities or differences do you see between pope joan and saint joan of arc. Considered by most scholars and the catholic church to be merely a legend, the story of a 9th century woman pope named joan continues to have a hold on the publics imagination. In its original incarnation, the film contained many flashbacks and flashforwards, quite a progressive style for 1972. Pope joan 1972 michael anderson, liv ullmann, jeremy kemp.
He teaches joan latin and greek and forges a close fatherly relationship with her, an escape from the horrific treatment. Pope joan 1972 michael anderson, liv ullmann, jeremy kemp, natasa nicolescu, drama april 24, 2016 a presentday female evangelist strongly feels that she resembles the legendary pope joan and goes to see her psychiatrist in hopes of discovering that shes pope joan incarnate. Angelicuss fate may not have been such a brutal one however. Pope joan quotes by donna woolfolk cross goodreads. The movie presents her existence as fact, though it is questionable that pope joan really did exist, and portrays her relationships with other notables of the time. Pope joan is a 1972 american historical drama film based on the story of pope joan. Also in 2009, another film with the title pope joan was released, this one a german. The final scene, where the crowd lynch their pope, was little more than a playground brawl.
Johanna wokalek, david wenham, john goodman, iain glen en edward petherbridge. Her story first appeared in chronicles in the th century and subsequently spread throughout europe. Such a dedicated, knowledgable and respected monk would have proven an ideal candidate to become pope. Pope joan is the story of a medievalera young woman who is intellectually brilliant and motivated in her desire to learn all she can about religion and medicine. May 19, 2009 pope joan soundtrack cd details and availability. The greek writer emmanouel rhoides wrote in the 1860s a book called papissa ioanna the popess joane, which was translated in many european languages. Over time joan, disguised as john anglicus, is eventually afforded opportunities at levels of power that most men never reach. The processes and materials of abstract expressionist painting. In the full version, a modernday woman evangelist, played by ullman, who feels an affinity to the legendary pope joan, pays a visit to her psychiatrist keir dullea. No one knows for sure if pope joan, or pope john anglicus as she called herself, really existed. The british version of the film has been cut, not only removing twentyone minutes of the film but also an entire contemporary framing story.
The poem is a dramtic monologue in which the narrator seems to be talking to an unnamed, invisible listener, explaining her experience of being pope joan. Pope joan is an international epic film produced by bernd eichinger, based on american novelist donna woolfolk cross novel of the same name about the legend. Based on what some consider mere fable and others claim as catholic apocrypha, this is the story of a 9th century pope who turned out to be a woman. The fable of pope joan catholic education resource center. An ordinary pack is used, from which the eight of diamonds has been removed, and a special round board in the form of eight compartments, named respectively popejoan, matrimony, intrigue, ace, king, queen, knave and game king, queen and knave are sometimes omitted.
The film portrays saint peter reflecting on his time with jesus and. Suddenly, shes transported back 1,000 years, when joan is the mistress of artistic monk adrian. Last night as part of sydneys german film fest, we saw pope joan or pope john viii and met the director,sonke wortmann, at a followup question time. Pope joan was a decent good historical movie and what it lacked in the visual arts, made up in strength of plot and screenplay. Although it is questionable that pope joan really did exist, this movie presents her existence as fact, and portrays her relationships with other notables of the time. Peters, she went into labour and gave birth to a child at the roadside historically unsubstantiated vocabulary transubstantiate. The greek author emmanuel rhoides 1866 novel, the papess joanne, was admired.
1388 1432 1507 1325 887 1588 798 655 529 1421 1321 868 1162 718 1220 606 1389 318 647 1147 793 727 243 1646 313 854 313 1240 488 1089 751 350 670 175 191 134 94 1501 1172 873 754 1075 1395 893 53 677